10/14/02 Ryan Adams Reported set list:  Previous
Ryman Auditorium Tomorrow Next
Nashville, TN Oh My Sweet Carolina
Sweet Lil' Gal (23rd/1st)
To Be Young (Is To Be Sad, Is To Be High)
The Fools We Are As Men
Brown Sugar
<Ryan plays along to Madonna "Like A Virgin">
Bartering Lines
SYLVIA PLATH
Improv "Cookie Monster" impression / singing
When The Stars Go Blue
Dear Chicago
Lovesick Blues
The Rescue Blues
<Ryan plays along to Minor Threat>
You Will Always Be The Same
La Cienega Just Smiled

Encore:  

Ryan Adams & The Esquires *
Tell Me Why

What Sin
Rosalie Come & Go
Joey (Bob Dylan) **
Come Pick Me Up
  1. Tegan & Sara opened.  Ryan performed on a few songs.
  2. Ryan Adams (vocals/guitar/piano/harmonica); Ruth Gottlieb (violin/vocals); Sarah Wilson (cello/piano).
  3. Also, Gilliian & David backed Ryan on a few tracks throughout the night.
  4. * Encore was with Gillian Welch & David Rawlings.
  5. ** Ryan on drums.
Review:
Review: Ryan Adams squanders opportunity and talent as Ryman show takes bizarre twists

By PETER COOPER
Staff Writer

Somebody should smack this kid, or praise this kid.

Somebody should listen to this kid, or get this kid to shut up.

The kid in question — and actually he's a 27-year-old man — is troubadour Ryan Adams, who offered ego, melody, mockery and soul during his bizarre, mostly acoustic Monday night show at the Ryman Auditorium.

Opening with two stellar ballads (including the indescribably gorgeous Oh My Sweet Carolina) that featured Gillian Welch and David Rawlings on harmony vocals, Adams' lilting, North Carolina-bred voice immediately drew attention, hushing a boozy crowd.

For a moment, he seemed triumphant, reining in the nervousness that must come with a first solo show in the storied Ryman hall and answering any doubters with sheer talent and musicality.

Then things got really weird.

Among the lowlights:

• An odd, elongated book reading.

• Two full-length, half-hearted Karaoke turns (one on Madonna's Like A Virgin, the other on a song from punkish, hardcore band Minor Threat) where Adams sporadically sang along with an amplified record player

• Numerous between-song ramblings that were sometimes amusing (the Cookie Monster sings Oh My Sweet Carolina bit) but more often awkward.

• An incident in which Adams turned a joking audience members' request for a Bryan Adams song (Get it? Bryan Adams?) into an altogether ugly situation (see Brad About You on page A3 for details).

• A radically altered, dirge-like, piano/vocal take on the Rolling Stones' Brown Sugar, which initially garnered ''Wow, listen to what he's done with Brown Sugar'' reactions but eventually landed in ''I wish he would quit doing that to Brown Sugar right NOW!'' terrain.

Occasionally, Adams would emerge from all the foolishness with a well-written, well-performed composition like When The Stars Go Blue or Bartering Lines. More often, he mired himself in the gummy muck of self-indulgence.

The wine kept flowing, the cigarettes kept spewing smoke (Adams was exempted from the Ryman's normally strict no-smoking policy), the reins got looser and the artist failed to deliver. Elliptical became obtuse, loose became frayed, and refreshingly in-the-moment became unprofessional and even contemptuous.

Though perhaps 20 percent of the audience left the building during the show, the majority of fans stayed ever-true, shouting encouragement and waiting for the derailed train to right itself.

''Everybody wants to see you suffer,'' Adams sang in Rescue Blues. Really? At the Ryman, most everyone merely wanted to hear him make music. We got some of that, but more of the puerile hoo-ha. Is Ryan Adams genuinely tortured or merely infantile? Either way, he blew it Monday night.

Peter Cooper writes about music for The Tennessean. He can be reached at 615-259-8220 or by e-mail at pcooper@tennessean.com.

Ryan's Alleged Voicemail Response:
Rocker and one-time Nashvillian Ryan Adams made quite an impression at his Ryman show Monday night. Tennessean music writer Peter Cooper described an incident in which Ryan went off on a guy who jokingly requested a Bryan Adams song, a story that now has been reported around the world. Peter also wrote a less-than-flattering review. Ryan left Peter a less-than-flattering voice mail. Here 'tis: ''You're just so smart, aren't you, man? You're so (expletive) smart. 'I'm so smart. I'm so post-collegiate with all my (expletive) little references.' 'Punkish hardcore.' What about 'Quintessential (expletive) band,' moron? ''What the (expletive) is wrong with you? Little redneck newspaper. Ooh, The Tennessean. Blah, blah, blah, blah. Whatever. You wouldn't know a (expletive) good show if it bit you in the (expletive). ''You and your senior citizen, little redneck (expletive) (expletive). Whatever, you know? Let's like … let's create it, let's judge it, you know? Like, 'Let's turn it into what it's supposed to be.' But you don't know (expletive). You and your (expletive) (expletive) paper. (Expletive) you.''
Robbie Fulks Lame-Ass Response:
We here at RobbieFulks.Com find that just too damn funny. So much in fact that Robbie made this offer:

"Any reader on this site who attends a Ryan Adams show and disrupts the show with a Bryan Adams song request will receive in return merchandise of his or her choice, equal to the cost of the ticket, from my online store. You're on the honor system, necessarily; but please provide the date and location of the show, what you yelled, and what Ryan's reaction was."
Sara Quin's (of Tegan & Sara) Comments:
"It wasn't like this guy was suddenly, like, "Hey! Play Summer Of 69.' He'd say shit between every song and be noisy and shoot off his mouth like a total asshole every chance he got.

"We were playing this amazing place where everyone was completely quiet, and people in the audience were telling him to shut up. Ryan finally confronted the dude 'cause he was ruining the show for everyone else."

Part of www.AnsweringBell.com